A two-story red brick house with a front porch beside a white brick cottage with a red roof on East Fletcher Avenue in the Fletcher Place area of Indianapolis, with the Mark Dietel Realty logo.
Published ·7 min read

What if the buyer's inspection finds a major problem in Indiana?

You can repair, credit, lower the price or decline. Decide with the next buyer in mind: once you know about a defect, it belongs on your Indiana disclosure.

Updated: November 22, 2026 · By Mark Dietel, Broker/Owner, Mark Dietel Realty · 7-minute read

Quick answer: You can repair it, offer a credit, lower the price or say no, and the buyer can usually accept, counter or cancel within the purchase agreement's deadlines. At Mark Dietel Realty we tell Indiana sellers to decide with the next buyer in mind, because once you know about a defect, it belongs on your disclosure form.

What we analyzed: Indiana's seller disclosure law (Indiana Code 32-21-5), the Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure (State Form 46234) and MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative closed residential sales in Marion County that MLS rules allow us to publish, from November 21, 2025 to November 20, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Indiana does not require a seller to make inspection repairs.
  • Your purchase agreement, not state law, sets the response deadlines.
  • If the buyer walks away, the defect belongs on your disclosure for the next buyer.
  • A buyer who gets an amended disclosure showing a defect after their offer is accepted can cancel within 2 business days under Indiana law.
  • More than half of Marion County homes sold this past year were built before 1978, so big findings on older systems are common in Indianapolis.

More in this series: how to choose a home inspector in Indianapolis and how to get your Indianapolis house ready for the inspection.

What counts as a major problem on an Indiana inspection?

A major problem is usually expensive, a health or safety risk, or likely to shorten the life of the house: an aging roof, foundation movement, water in the basement, an old electrical panel, a failing furnace or a broken sewer line. Indiana's disclosure law calls this kind of issue a defect.

Indiana Code 32-21-5-4 defines a defect as a condition that would significantly hurt the home's value, significantly impair the health or safety of future occupants, or significantly shorten the home's expected normal life if not fixed, so a dripping faucet does not qualify.

In Indianapolis, the sewer line is a common surprise. Citizens Energy Group makes the owner responsible for the sewer lateral, the pipe from the house to the main, so a camera inspection that finds a break leaves the seller with that item to answer.

Big findings also come up often here because of age. In MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative sales this past year, more than half of Marion County homes sold were built before 1978, the cutoff year for the federal lead-based paint disclosure rule. For a seller, that means more original roofs, panels, furnaces and sewer lines for a buyer's inspector to flag.

55.6% of Marion County homes sold from November 2025 to November 2026 were built before 1978; median year built 1971.
Older homes mean more original systems for a buyer's inspector to flag.

Marion County homes sold, past 12 months: how old they were

AreaClosed salesMedian year builtBuilt before 1978
Marion County11,318197155.6%

What are your options when the inspection finds a major defect?

You have four: make the repair before closing, give the buyer a credit, lower the price, or decline. The buyer then accepts, counters or, if the purchase agreement allows it, cancels. Each answer changes what you walk away with and how likely the sale is to close.

Your four answers to a major inspection finding

AnswerWhat it meansFits whenTrade-off
Repair before closingA licensed contractor fixes it; the buyer gets the invoiceYou have time, cash and a clear fixCash out before closing
Credit at closingYou cover part of the buyer's costs insteadThe buyer wants their own contractorThe buyer's loan must allow it
Lower the priceA written amendment changes the priceThe fix is large or hard to priceLess cash for you
DeclineTerms stay as writtenThe issue was disclosed or priced inThe buyer may cancel

How long do you have to answer? As long as your purchase agreement says. Indiana sets no single statewide deadline, and the inspection period, your response time and the buyer's reply time are all in the contract, so check those dates as soon as the repair request arrives.

Our read at Mark Dietel Realty, from experience rather than data: a credit often keeps a sale together when the buyer wants their own contractor and their loan allows it.

Not sure which answer fits your house? Call (317) 426-9911 to talk it through with a Mark Dietel Realty agent.

Do you have to disclose the problem if the buyer walks away?

In practice, yes. Indiana's Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure, State Form 46234, asks about the known condition of the home, and once an inspection shows you a defect, you know about it. Your next buyer should see it on the form before you accept their offer, and a real estate attorney can help you word the update.

Indiana Code 32-21-5-10 requires the completed form before an offer is accepted. Under Indiana Code 32-21-5-13, a buyer who receives a disclosure form or an amended form after acceptance that shows a defect can cancel within 2 business days and get their deposit back.

Key takeaway card: once an inspection shows you a defect, it belongs on your disclosure for the next buyer.
What you learn from the inspection stays with the house.

What does this look like in Central Indiana?

Here is a hypothetical example. Say you accept a $280,000 offer on a 1950s ranch in Beech Grove. The buyer's sewer camera inspection shows a broken clay sewer lateral, and the buyer's agent asks you to replace it before closing.

You get a plumber's written quote and offer a closing credit for that amount, which the buyer's lender allows. The buyer accepts in a written amendment and the sale closes on time. Had the buyer walked away, the broken line would go on your updated disclosure for the next buyer.

When this doesn't apply

What to do next

Get the full report section and a contractor's written quote, then compare what each answer would leave you with at closing before your response deadline.

Prefer to talk? Call (317) 426-9911. Mark Dietel Realty has offices in Southside Indianapolis, Greenwood and Bloomington.

Frequently asked questions

Can the buyer back out because of the inspection?

Often, yes, if the purchase agreement gives them an inspection contingency and they act inside its deadline. The inspection period, response times and the buyer's options are written into the contract, so read yours. Outside that window, what the buyer can do depends on the terms you both signed.

Should you get a contractor to check the finding?

For a roof, foundation or sewer line, a licensed contractor in that trade gives you a written scope and price to answer with instead of a guess. Anything the contractor confirms is also something you know when you fill out a disclosure form later.

How long does a buyer have to cancel after an amended disclosure?

Under Indiana Code 32-21-5-13, a buyer who receives a disclosure form or an amended form after their offer is accepted, and that form shows a defect, can cancel within 2 business days of receiving it. They cancel in writing, delivered to the owner or the owner's agent, and get their deposit back.

Do you have to update your disclosure before closing?

Yes, in one of two ways. Indiana Code 32-21-5-12 requires the seller, at or before closing, to disclose any material change in the home's physical condition since the form was given, or certify that the condition is substantially the same. A real estate attorney can tell you which applies after a major finding.

Will a major defect end your sale?

Not usually by itself. From our experience at Mark Dietel Realty, not from data: many sales close after a big inspection finding once the seller and buyer agree on a repair, a credit or a price change. What ends sales more often is a gap the two sides cannot close, or a deadline that passes before anyone answers.

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Confirm your situation with a real estate attorney.

Mark Dietel Realty - offices in Indianapolis (Southside), Greenwood and Bloomington, Indiana.

Sources

Keep learning

Related guides

View Learning Center →

Ready to talk through your next move?

Our team helps Central Indiana buyers and sellers make confident decisions — with clear answers and a plan that fits your goals.