Updated: November 19, 2026 · By Mark Dietel, Broker/Owner, Mark Dietel Realty · 8-minute read
If an FHA appraisal on your Indiana home comes back "subject to" repairs, the loan cannot close until the lender confirms the fixes, so Mark Dietel Realty's advice is to clear a short safety list fast. Who pays follows your purchase agreement, and the longer the list or the thinner the buyer's cash, the more it becomes a price negotiation.
What we analyzed: HUD Handbook 4000.1, 24 CFR 200.810, Indiana's disclosure law (IC 32-21-5) and MIBOR MLS closed residential sales from November 18, 2025 to November 18, 2026.
What the local data adds: more than half of the Marion County homes sold in that year were built before 1978, the cutoff for HUD's peeling-paint check, against about a quarter in Johnson County. So an Indianapolis home is far more likely to fall under that check.
Key takeaways
- The appraiser lists the repairs; the buyer's lender decides which must be done before closing.
- Conditions cover safety, security and soundness. Worn carpet and a dated kitchen are cosmetic.
- Homes built before 1978 get a peeling-paint check; repainting the defective area usually clears it.
- Who pays is negotiated, and a closing credit does not clear a required repair.
- More than half of the Marion County homes sold this past year were built before 1978, so far more Indianapolis sales fall under the paint check than suburban ones.
This follows who orders the inspection, appraisal and survey in Indiana and what to do when the survey shows a problem.
What does "subject to repairs" mean on an FHA appraisal in Indiana?
It means the appraiser valued your home as if certain repairs were done, and the loan cannot close until they are. Under HUD's Handbook 4000.1, the appraiser notes each repair needed to meet HUD's property rules, with an estimated cost to cure (what the fix should cost), and the buyer's lender decides which are required.
So ask for the lender's condition list as well as the appraisal. The lender approves the home only after it confirms the defects were corrected; if an item cannot be finished before closing, HUD lets the lender set up a repair escrow, money held at closing until the work is done. An FHA appraisal stays valid for 180 days under HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11, so a slow repair usually moves your closing date rather than forcing a new appraisal.
If you already have a list in hand and want a second set of eyes on it, call (317) 426-9911 or use the options form further down this page.

Which repairs can an FHA appraiser require, and which are cosmetic?
HUD's minimum property requirements ask that every FHA home be safe, sound and secure. Items that threaten safety, let water in or leave the home without basic systems become conditions; cosmetic wear is noted but not required.
Common FHA appraisal findings and how they are usually treated
| Finding | Usually a repair condition? | Rule behind it |
|---|---|---|
| Peeling paint, home built before 1978 | Yes | 24 CFR 200.810 (repainting counts) |
| No working heat, hot water or kitchen sink | Yes | Handbook 4000.1, living unit minimums |
| Staying appliance that does not work | Yes | Handbook 4000.1, appliances |
| Signs of termites | Yes, often a pest inspection | Handbook 4000.1, termites |
| Worn carpet, dated kitchen | No | Cosmetic |
HUD has posted draft revisions that would rename these rules Property Acceptability Criteria; until they are final, lenders follow the current handbook.
Who pays for FHA-required repairs when you sell in Indiana?
No Indiana statute assigns the cost; your purchase agreement and negotiation do. The Indiana Association of REALTORS Purchase Agreement (Improved Property) says inspections and charges required by the lender, FHA, VA or a mortgage insurer follow those agencies' rules. It does not make the seller pay for every repair.
Sellers usually choose one of three paths. Older homes, which make up most Indianapolis sales in the table below, are the ones that fall under the pre-1978 paint check.
- Fix the items yourself. This fits a short list you can finish well inside the appraisal's 180-day window.
- Let the buyer pay. This fits a buyer with cash to spare. HUD lets the lender add required repair costs to the loan when the contract names the buyer as responsible (Handbook 4000.1, section II.A.2.a.v). The amount is capped at the lowest of three numbers: the appraiser's estimate, the contractor's bid, or how much the value exceeds the price. Put access and insurance in writing.
- Renegotiate price or terms, or end the deal if your contract allows it. This fits a long list or a buyer with little cash.
A closing credit alone does not satisfy the lender, because the condition is about the house. Compare written bids with the appraiser's cost estimate before you agree.

How do repairs get done and checked before closing?
The lender needs proof the work is finished before it will fund the loan. Often the appraiser returns for a short completion check with photos. For some items the lender accepts a contractor's invoice or a pest control report instead. Ask which proof applies to each item, and book it the day the work ends.
- Get the lender's required-repair list in writing.
- Sign an amendment saying who does each item and by when.
- For paint on a pre-1978 home, use a contractor who follows EPA lead-safe rules (see lead paint rules for pre-1978 Indiana homes).
- Keep receipts for your records.
If the deal falls apart, you now know about the listed conditions. Ask your agent or attorney whether to update your Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure (State Form 46234, under IC 32-21-5) before the next buyer signs; under IC 32-21-5-10, a buyer's or lender's appraiser can request a copy.
How many Central Indiana homes fall under FHA's pre-1978 paint check?
It depends heavily on the county. In MIBOR MLS data, more than half of the Marion County homes sold in the past year were built before 1978, the cutoff for HUD's paint check. In Johnson County it was about a quarter.
Homes sold by year built, November 18, 2025 to November 18, 2026 (MIBOR MLS, closed residential sales)
| County | Closed sales | Built before 1978 | Share built before 1978 | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marion | 11,326 | 6,297 | 55.6% | 1970 |
| Johnson | 2,430 | 599 | 24.7% | 2000 |
| Hendricks | 2,670 | 527 | 19.7% | 2003 |
| Hamilton | 6,443 | 639 | 9.9% | 2006 |
For a Southside Indianapolis seller with a 1950s or 1960s home, repainting peeling trim before listing is easier than doing it under an FHA deadline. In Hendricks County about one in five homes sold fell under the paint check, and in Hamilton County about one in ten, so sellers there and in 2000s Greenwood subdivisions are less likely to see a paint condition, though roofs and mechanicals still come up.
Our view at Mark Dietel Realty: Spend first on what a home inspector will find: roof, mechanicals, water, safety items, deferred maintenance. That is where repair money most often protects the sale.
What does this look like in Central Indiana?
A hypothetical, not a real client: a seller accepts a $240,000 FHA offer on a 1962 Southside Indianapolis ranch. The appraisal meets the price, subject to peeling exterior trim, a range that stays but does not work, and a pest inspection after signs of termites.
Hypothetical: one way the three conditions could be handled
| Condition | Who handles it (as negotiated) | Proof for the lender |
|---|---|---|
| Peeling trim (built 1962) | Seller hires a lead-safe painter | Completion check |
| Range does not work | Seller repairs it, or it leaves with the seller | Invoice or completion check |
| Possible termites | Buyer orders inspection; seller treats if active | Pest control report |
Before you sign an amendment, request a written net sheet showing repair bids and your negotiated agent compensation (enter yours).
When this doesn't apply
- Cash buyers and most conventional loans do not use HUD's property rules, though their appraisers can still flag condition.
- VA loans follow VA's own property requirements, which are similar but not identical.
- FHA 203(k) loans, which let a buyer borrow for the purchase and the renovation in one mortgage, build repairs in by design.
- A low value is a different problem; see what to do when the appraisal comes in low.
- If you plan no repairs at all, read whether you can sell as-is in Indiana before accepting a financed offer.
What to do next
Ask for the lender's written condition list, get two bids and decide within a few days. In our experience, the biggest risk with most FHA repair lists is the calendar, since every day spent on the list can push the closing.
Prefer to talk? Call (317) 426-9911. Mark Dietel Realty has offices in Southside Indianapolis, Greenwood and Bloomington.
Frequently asked questions
Can the buyer waive an FHA repair condition?
No. The condition belongs to the lender and HUD. A buyer can drop their own inspection requests, but an FHA loan cannot close until the lender confirms required repairs are done or escrowed. If neither side handles them, the buyer may need a different loan, or the deal may end under your contract.
Does a seller have to make FHA-required repairs in Indiana?
Not automatically. Indiana law does not force a seller to repair a home for a buyer's loan; your purchase agreement and amendments decide. If you refuse and the buyer cannot pay, the loan cannot close, so weigh the repair cost against starting over with a new buyer.
Will the appraiser come back to check the work?
Often, yes. Many lenders send the appraiser back for a short completion check with photos, while others accept a contractor's invoice or a pest control report for certain items. Ask the buyer's lender which proof it needs for each item, so the check can be booked the day the work is finished.
Do FHA paint rules apply if my home was built after 1978?
The lead paint check applies only to homes built before 1978. A newer home can still get a condition when peeling exterior paint exposes the surface underneath to the weather, because HUD treats that as a soundness issue rather than a lead hazard. Faded or scuffed interior paint is cosmetic.
This is general information, not legal, tax or appraisal advice. Confirm your situation with the buyer's lender, a licensed appraiser or an Indiana real estate attorney.
Mark Dietel Realty - offices in Indianapolis (Southside), Greenwood and Bloomington, Indiana.
Sources
- HUD Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 (current handbook)
- HUD FHA Drafting Table: proposed revisions to Handbook 4000.1 property requirements
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2022-11, Revised Appraisal Validity Periods
- 24 CFR Part 200, Subpart O (200.805 and 200.810), Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention (eCFR)
- McKissock Learning, Cosmetic vs. MPR Repairs: Guidance for FHA Appraisers
- Indiana Association of REALTORS Purchase Agreement (Improved Property), member form
- Indiana Code 32-21-5 (residential real estate sales disclosure) and State Form 46234, Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure
- MIBOR MLS closed residential sales, November 18, 2025 to November 18, 2026, IDX records, aggregated by Mark Dietel Realty
- Based on information submitted to the Broker Listing Cooperative listing service as of November 19, 2026. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or Broker Listing Cooperative listing service.




