Two older bungalows on Maynard Drive in the Homecroft area on the Southside of Indianapolis, one green with red shutters and one yellow, with winter lawns and bare trees, with the Mark Dietel Realty logo.
Published ·7 min read

Which contingencies should you keep when buying in Indianapolis?

Keep inspection, financing and appraisal contingencies on most Indianapolis purchases, plus the lead-paint test on pre-1978 homes. Here's how to decide.

Updated: November 21, 2026 · By Mark Dietel, Broker/Owner, Mark Dietel Realty · 7-minute read

Quick answer: On most Indianapolis purchases, keep the inspection, financing and appraisal contingencies, plus the federal lead-paint testing window on homes built before 1978, and waive one only if you could absorb the loss it protects against. Our read at Mark Dietel Realty is that shorter Indiana deadlines make an offer stronger with less risk than dropping a protection.

What we analyzed: MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative closed residential sales in Marion, Johnson, Hamilton and Hendricks counties from August 22 to November 19, 2026, plus Indiana Code 32-21-5, the EPA/HUD lead-based paint disclosure rule and HUD's FHA amendatory clause.

Key takeaways

  • A contingency is a written condition that lets you cancel and get your earnest money back if something specific goes wrong.
  • Inspection, financing and appraisal protect most Indianapolis buyers from the biggest losses.
  • More than half of Marion County sales over the last three months were homes built before 1978, so the federal lead-paint testing window comes up on most Indianapolis purchases.
  • Indiana and federal rules give you a few protections that stay in place even when you waive a contingency.
  • Before you offer, decide which deadlines you can shorten and book an inspector early. To talk through a specific home, call Mark Dietel Realty at (317) 426-9911.

What is a contingency in an Indiana purchase agreement?

A contingency is a condition written into your purchase agreement. If it is not met by its deadline, you can cancel and get your earnest money back. Each runs on its own clock, usually from the day the seller accepts. If a deadline passes and you have not acted, you can lose that protection, so track every date in writing.

These deadlines are a big part of why an accepted offer takes about a month to close. In Marion County, the median time from signed contract to closing was 31 days over the last three months. Our guide to how long it takes to buy a house in Indianapolis walks through each step on that clock.

Which contingencies should Indianapolis buyers keep?

Keep the contingencies that protect money you cannot afford to lose. For most Indianapolis buyers that means inspection, financing and appraisal. On a house built before 1978, keep the lead-paint testing window too. Keep a home-sale contingency if you cannot carry two mortgages, and keep title review in every offer you write in Indiana.

Contingency decision guide

ContingencyWhat it protectsKeep it whenWaiving can make sense when
InspectionLets you inspect, ask for repairs or a credit, or cancelAlmost always; Indiana's seller disclosure (State Form 46234) is not a warrantyYou are paying cash for a house you plan to renovate and can cover major surprises
Financing (loan approval)Lets you cancel if your lender does not approve the loanYou are borrowing any part of the priceYou are paying cash or could close with cash if the loan failed
AppraisalLets you renegotiate or cancel if the home appraises below the priceYour down payment cannot stretch to cover a gap (FHA and VA buyers also have HUD's amendatory clause)You have cash set aside to cover a gap and still want the house
Lead-based paint testA federal 10-day window to test homes built before 1978The house is pre-1978, as most Marion County sales areYou already plan lead abatement work and accept the finding either way
Sale of your current homeLets you cancel if your current home does not sellYou need that sale to afford the new paymentYou can carry both homes for several months
HOA documentsTime to read the rules, budget and dues (IC 32-21-5-8.5)The home is in a homeowners associationRarely; reading them costs little
TitleLets you object to liens or ownership problemsEvery purchaseNever

For what an inspector looks at on a typical Central Indiana house, see what a home inspection covers when buying in Indiana.

Why does the age of the house matter so much in Indianapolis?

Most homes sold in Marion County are old enough to fall under the federal lead-based paint disclosure rule. Under the EPA/HUD rule, sellers of most housing built before 1978 must give buyers a 10-day opportunity to test for lead-based paint. Buyer and seller can agree in writing to lengthen or shorten that window, and a buyer can waive it.

The window comes up far more often inside Indianapolis than in the suburbs around it. Over the last three months, more than half of Marion County sales were homes built before 1978. In Johnson and Hendricks counties it was about one in five, and in Hamilton County about one in ten.

Share of closed sales built before 1978

CountyClosed sales built before 1978Median days, contract to close
Marion58%31
Johnson22%31
Hendricks22%31
Hamilton11%31

Source: MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative, IDX residential closed sales, August 22 to November 19, 2026.

In our experience, older homes also bring the inspection findings that make an inspection contingency worth keeping, such as original sewer lines and older electrical panels. On a pre-1978 house on the Southside or near downtown Indianapolis, the inspection is the protection we would least want to see dropped.

What protections do you keep even if you waive a contingency?

A few protections come from Indiana law or federal loan rules, so they stay with you even when you waive a contingency in the contract. They work alongside an inspection and do not take its place.

  • Indiana Code 32-21-5 requires the seller to give you the Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure (State Form 46234) before your offer is accepted. The form is not a warranty. If a defect is disclosed after acceptance, IC 32-21-5-13 lets you cancel in writing within 2 business days and get your deposits back.
  • For a home in an association, IC 32-21-5-8.5 requires the seller to provide certain association information no later than 10 days before closing.
  • If you use an FHA or VA loan, HUD's amendatory clause says you are not obligated to complete the purchase or forfeit earnest money when the appraised value comes in below the price. You can still choose to go ahead.

Should you waive contingencies to win a multiple-offer situation?

Rarely. When an Indianapolis home draws several offers, a shorter inspection window, a firm loan approval date or a pre-approval letter from a local lender often does more than a waived contingency. In our experience, sellers look closely at how likely each offer is to close. If you do waive one, waive only what you can afford to lose, because a failed roof or a short appraisal becomes your cost.

In Marion County, where most recent sales were pre-1978 homes, we would keep the inspection and shorten its deadline before giving it up. On a newer home with a clean seller disclosure, a shorter appraisal window can be a reasonable trade if you have cash set aside.

Myth vs fact card: waiving the inspection is not the only way to compete; the Indiana seller disclosure is not a warranty; Indiana disclosure law and HUD's FHA appraisal clause still apply after a waiver; the federal lead-paint rule covers most housing built before 1978.
Four common contingency beliefs, and what Indiana and federal rules say.

What does this look like in Central Indiana?

Here is a hypothetical example. A buyer using an FHA loan offers $275,000 on a 1950s ranch on the Southside of Indianapolis, and two other offers come in. Instead of waiving the inspection, the buyer shortens the inspection window and agrees in writing to a shorter lead-paint testing window.

The appraisal comes in below the price. Because of HUD's amendatory clause, the buyer can renegotiate or walk away with the earnest money. The seller agrees to meet in the middle and the closing date holds.

When this doesn't apply

This advice fits most financed purchases of existing homes. Cash buyers do not need a financing contingency. New construction runs on the builder's own contract, which often limits contingencies. Bank-owned and foreclosure sales may be sold as-is, and the lead-paint rule does not cover foreclosure sales. If your situation involves a divorce, an estate or a legal dispute, talk with a real estate attorney before you sign.

What to do next

Checklist of eight steps before writing an offer in Indianapolis, from reading the seller disclosure to keeping title review in every offer.
Work through this list before you write, so a short contingency window still works for you.

Decide which contingencies you will shorten and which you will not give up before you write. If you want to talk through an offer on a specific Indianapolis home, call Mark Dietel Realty at (317) 426-9911. We have offices in Southside Indianapolis, Greenwood and Bloomington. When you are ready for the last step, read what happens at closing when you buy a house in Indianapolis.

Frequently asked questions

Can I back out of buying a house in Indiana without a contingency?

You can try, but you may lose your earnest money and could face a claim from the seller. Outside your contingencies, Indiana law gives a narrow exit: if the seller discloses a defect after your offer is accepted, you can cancel in writing within 2 business days. Ask a real estate attorney before canceling for any other reason.

What happens to my earnest money if I cancel under a contingency?

If you cancel within the deadline and follow the notice steps in your contract, your earnest money is usually returned. The money is held by the title company or a broker until the parties sign a release. Read the release terms in your purchase agreement before you make your offer.

Does a cash buyer in Indianapolis need any contingencies?

A cash buyer does not need a financing contingency, but inspection and title protections still matter, and a short inspection window makes sense for most cash buyers. On a house built before 1978, the federal lead-paint testing opportunity applies to cash and financed buyers alike unless it is waived in writing.

Can a seller keep showing the house while my contingencies are open?

That depends on your purchase agreement. Some sellers keep accepting backup offers while a buyer's contingencies are open, so they have a next offer ready if the first one falls through. If you meet each deadline in writing, a backup offer usually moves up only on the terms your purchase agreement sets for canceling or missed dates.

Is a home-sale contingency hard to get accepted in Indianapolis?

It can be when several buyers want the same house, because the seller would be waiting on two sales instead of one. It is easier on homes that have been on the market longer. Having your current home listed, or already under contract, makes the offer stronger and easier for a seller to accept.

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Confirm your situation with a real estate attorney, CPA or lender.

Mark Dietel Realty - offices in Indianapolis (Southside), Greenwood and Bloomington, Indiana.

Sources

Keep learning

Related guides

View Learning Center →

Ready to talk through your next move?

Our team helps Central Indiana buyers and sellers make confident decisions — with clear answers and a plan that fits your goals.