A row of small wood-sided houses with gabled roofs behind a long white picket fence on McCarty Street in Indianapolis, with the Mark Dietel Realty logo.
Published ·7 min read

What if the survey shows a problem when you sell in Indiana?

Start with a retracement survey: the lender's report allows a foot or two of error. Then move the item, record an agreement with the neighbor, or close with a title exception.

Updated: November 18, 2026 · By Mark Dietel, Broker/Owner, Mark Dietel Realty · 7-minute read

Quick answer: At Mark Dietel Realty, our first step with a Central Indiana survey problem is a retracement survey, because the lender's report allows a foot or two of error. Next steps depend on which side of the line the item sits and whether the neighbor cooperates: move it, record an agreement, or close with a title exception.

What we analyzed: Indiana's surveyor rules for location reports (865 IAC 1-12-27 and 1-12-28, current through June 25, 2025), the Indiana Code sections on adverse possession, and an Indiana Court of Appeals decision from September 2025. This post uses no market data.

The detail that changes the next step: the report that "found a problem" is a location check with a built-in margin, written for the lender's title insurance. A retracement survey by a licensed Indiana surveyor is what tells you whether the problem is real.

Key takeaways

  • In most financed Indiana home sales, the survey is a surveyor location report ordered through the title company for the lender.
  • Indiana's rule lets that report be off by up to a foot in a recorded subdivision and 2 feet on other tracts, and it sets no corner markers.
  • A neighbor's long use of your land is a legal question with strict Indiana conditions, so bring in a real estate attorney before signing anything.

What does an Indiana surveyor location report actually show?

A surveyor location report is the quick check most title companies order for a lender on a one-to-four family home. Under 865 IAC 1-12-28, it shows the house, driveway, fences, sheds and other visible items, measures the distance from each to the nearest boundary or easement line, and marks any building over an easement or setback line.

An easement is a recorded right for someone else, such as a utility, to use a strip of your lot. A setback line is the minimum distance a building must sit from a lot line under a plat, covenant or zoning rule.

The rule says those distances exist "to reveal the extent of any possible encroachment," meaning something on one lot that crosses onto another.

It has limits. Rule 865 IAC 1-12-27 says no corner monuments have to be set, so nobody drives a new stake at the corners. The measured location can be off by up to one foot in a recorded subdivision. On other tracts the margin is up to two feet.

Its certificate has to be dated within 30 days of delivery, so the report from the day you bought will not carry over. If a new report shows something near a line, call your listing agent the day it arrives, or reach us at (317) 426-9911.

Which survey findings tend to hold up a closing?

In our experience at Mark Dietel Realty, the findings that slow a closing are a building over an easement or setback line, a neighbor's fence, shed or driveway on your lot, and something of yours on theirs. A fence a few inches off the line, inside the report's margin, may need only the title company's sign-off.

Survey findings and the usual next step in an Indiana sale

What the report showsWhat it can meanUsual next stepWho usually handles it
Fence a few inches from the lineIt may sit inside the report's 1 to 2 foot marginAsk the surveyor; order a retracement survey if the title company asksListing agent, surveyor
Neighbor's fence, shed or driveway on your lotA possible encroachmentRetracement survey, then removal or a recorded agreementSeller, neighbor, real estate attorney
Your fence, shed or deck on the neighbor's lotThe buyer could inherit a disputeMove it, or sign a recorded agreement before closingSeller, neighbor, attorney
Building over a recorded easementThe easement holder may have rights to that stripTitle company review; a release from the easement holder if neededTitle company, attorney
Building over a setback lineA possible zoning or covenant questionCheck with the local planning office or the homeowners associationSeller, title company
Regulated drain on or within 75 feet of the lotThe county may hold drainage rightsTitle company decides whether it becomes a listed exceptionTitle company, county surveyor
Yes/no path: if the item is within the report's margin, ask the surveyor and title company; if a neighbor claims or has long used the strip, call a real estate attorney; if a building sits over an easement or setback line, start with the title company; otherwise order a retracement survey.
Who a seller usually calls first, depending on what the surveyor location report shows. Source: 865 IAC 1-12-27 and 1-12-28; Indiana Code 32-21-7-1 and 34-11-2-11.

How do you fix a fence or shed that crosses the line?

Start by confirming the line. A licensed Indiana surveyor can do a retracement survey, which finds or sets the corner markers that a location report skips. If the encroachment is real, the usual fixes are moving the item, a written agreement with the neighbor recorded with the county, or a deed for the strip that a real estate attorney prepares.

Each of these takes time, so tell the buyer's side as soon as the report comes in and ask for a written extension of the closing date if you need one. If the neighbor will not cooperate, the buyer and lender decide whether to accept it as a title exception (an item the title policy lists and does not cover), ask for a price change, or use their rights under the contract.

Five-step chart: read the surveyor location report, confirm the line with a retracement survey, talk with the neighbor, put any agreement in writing and record it, then clear it with the title company before closing.
The usual order of steps when an Indiana surveyor location report shows a fence, shed or building near a line. Source: 865 IAC 1-12-27 and 1-12-28; Indiana Code 32-21-7-1.

Can a neighbor claim part of your yard in Indiana?

Possibly, though Indiana sets a high bar. Indiana courts apply a 10-year period under Indiana Code 34-11-2-11, and Indiana Code 32-21-7-1 adds that the person claiming the land must have paid the taxes and special assessments they believed in good faith were due on it. They must also prove every other element, so treat this as a question for an attorney.

The Indiana Court of Appeals applied these rules in September 2025 in Brown v. Charles Sturdevant Post of the American Legion Post 46.

Who pays to fix a survey problem?

The purchase agreement decides. A problem with your title is usually yours to clear, because you promised to deliver the house as described. An extra survey the buyer orders for their own reasons is usually theirs. Ask for a written net sheet, a line-by-line estimate of what you walk away with, that lists any survey, attorney or recording cost.

The pillar post on who orders the inspection, appraisal and survey in Indiana covers who sets up each check in the first place.

What does this look like in Central Indiana?

Hypothetical example, made-up numbers: a Greenwood owner in Johnson County accepts a $280,000 offer on a 1990s ranch home. Two weeks before closing, the surveyor location report shows the neighbor's privacy fence about 2 feet inside the seller's side line. Because the lot sits in a recorded subdivision, the report's margin is one foot, so it is worth confirming.

Hypothetical Greenwood sale: one way the fence finding could be handled

StageWho actsWhat the seller does
Report arrivesTitle company sends it to both sidesRead it with the listing agent and ask what the margin is
Confirm the lineA licensed surveyor does a retracement surveyAgree on timing and ask the buyer's side for a short extension if needed
Talk with the neighborSeller, with the agent's helpChoose between the neighbor moving the fence and a recorded agreement
PaperworkA real estate attorney drafts; the Johnson County Recorder records itSign, then send the recorded copy to the title company
ClosingTitle company issues its commitment (its written promise of what it will insure), with or without an exceptionClose on the original date or the extended one

In this example the survey and attorney costs go on the seller's net sheet next to your negotiated agent compensation (enter yours). The bigger risk is time, so the talk with the neighbor starts the day the report arrives.

Should you get a survey before you list, or wait for the buyer's?

Our read: order a retracement survey before listing when your lot has an older fence, a shed or addition close to a line, or a shared driveway, because it turns a closing surprise into a known fact. On a newer lot in a recorded subdivision with nothing near the lines, waiting for the lender's location report is reasonable.

  • Survey first: you pay up front and learn the line before buyers do, and any fix runs on your schedule.
  • Wait: you save the cost, but any finding lands inside the contract deadlines.

When this doesn't apply

  • Cash sales: there may be no location report, though the buyer can order a survey.
  • Acreage, farmland and new lot splits: a location report is not allowed for nonresidential tracts over two acres, and a full boundary survey is the norm.
  • An active dispute or lawsuit with a neighbor: talk to a real estate attorney before you list.

What to do next

Prefer to talk? Call (317) 426-9911. Mark Dietel Realty has offices in Southside Indianapolis, Greenwood and Bloomington.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have to disclose a known survey problem in Indiana?

Indiana sellers of most homes complete the seller's disclosure, State Form 46234, and answer it based on what they actually know. If you know about a boundary dispute or a fence over the line, ask your listing agent and a real estate attorney how it should appear on the form before you sign it.

Can the buyer back out over a survey problem?

That depends on the survey, title and financing terms in your purchase agreement. If the lender will not lend with the problem in place, or the title company will not insure over it, the buyer may have a way out under the contract. Read the contract with your agent, and with an attorney if a deadline is close.

Does owner's title insurance cover encroachments?

It depends on the policy and on the survey exceptions in the title commitment. Coverage for boundary matters can differ based on whether the title company has a survey to rely on. Ask the title company what the commitment says about survey exceptions before closing. That document is what tells the buyer what the policy will cover.

What if my fence has been there for decades?

Age alone does not move a property line. Indiana's 10-year rule also requires good-faith payment of taxes on the land and proof of the other elements. A long-standing fence can still lead to a claim, so get the line confirmed and ask a real estate attorney before signing any agreement with the neighbor.

This is general information, not legal, tax or appraisal advice. Confirm your situation with your county recorder, a licensed Indiana surveyor or a real estate attorney.

Mark Dietel Realty - offices in Indianapolis (Southside), Greenwood and Bloomington, Indiana.

Sources

Keep learning

Related guides

View Learning Center →

Ready to talk through your next move?

Our team helps Central Indiana buyers and sellers make confident decisions — with clear answers and a plan that fits your goals.