Holy Cross, IN Real Estate Market: Home Prices (Oct 2025 to Sep 2026)

From October 2025 to September 2026, 36 home sales were recorded in the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association area, with a median sale price of $362,750, against $229,000 for Marion County (public sales records via STATS Indiana). The neighborhood's price level and the ZIP Code's differ widely: ZIP Code 46201 as a whole had a median sale price of $167,750 from August to October 2026, and months of inventory was 6.5 in October 2026 (Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub). What that means for a seller depends on their price range and their home's condition.

What we analyzed: home sales recorded in public records for the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association area and Marion County, October 2025 to September 2026, plus Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub figures for ZIP Code 46201 as a whole, October 2026 and the three weeks ending with the week of Oct. 26, 2026, as published.

Holy Cross home prices and days on market

Oct 2025 to Sep 2026

Recorded home sales: 36; Oct 2025 to Sep 2026
Median sale price: $362,750; Oct 2025 to Sep 2026
Middle half of sales: $258,100 to $420,000; Oct 2025 to Sep 2026
Marion County median: $229,000; Oct 2025 to Sep 2026

Source: Indiana Department of Local Government Finance sales disclosure data via STATS Indiana (stats.indiana.edu), home sales recorded in Marion County through September 2026; neighborhood boundary from the City of Indianapolis (IndyGIS); addresses located with the U.S. Census Bureau geocoder. Recorded sales include homes sold without a listing.

Why are Holy Cross sale prices so different from ZIP Code 46201 as a whole?

They measure different groups of homes. From October 2025 to September 2026, the 36 sales recorded in the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association area had a median of $362,750. ZIP Code 46201 as a whole had a median sale price of $167,750 from August to October 2026, as published by the Housing Hub.

Use the neighborhood's recorded sales to price a Holy Cross home, and the ZIP Code figures only to see how fast and how crowded the wider market around it is. The map below shows ZIP Code medians across Marion County, not the neighborhood's own.

Map of Marion County, Indiana ZIP Codes shaded by median sale price (3-month average), Aug 2026–Oct 2026. Holy Cross: 46201: $168K. Other ZIPs: 46107: $200K; 46113: $293K; 46183: too few sales; 46202: $465K; 46203: $190K; 46204: $345K; 46205: $300K; 46208: $235K; 46214: $242K; 46216: too few sales; 46217: $260K; 46218: $121K; 46219: $193K; 46220: $355K; 46221: $225K; 46222: $132K; 46224: $215K; 46225: $182K; 46226: $160K; 46227: $234K; 46228: $315K; 46229: $239K; 46231: $250K; 46234: $295K; 46235: $220K; 46236: $374K; 46237: $264K; 46239: $308K; 46240: $365K; 46241: $174K; 46250: $332K; 46254: $230K; 46256: $377K; 46259: $398K; 46260: $295K; 46268: $268K; 46278: $454K. — Median sale price (3-month average) by ZIP Code, Aug 2026–Oct 2026. Holy Cross's ZIPs are outlined. Source: Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub.

What price bands do Holy Cross homes sell in?

The largest group sold from $300,000 to $399,999: 13 of the 36 recorded sales (36%). Another 9 (25%) were from $400,000 to $599,999.

At the other end, 6 sales (17%) were under $200,000, 6 (17%) were from $200,000 to $299,999, and 2 (6%) were $600,000 and up. The middle half of sales ran from $258,100 to $420,000.

These figures are recorded home sales from public records, which include homes sold without a listing, so they can differ from listing-based figures. Marion County recorded 14,106 home sales over the same 12 months, with a median of $229,000.

How many Holy Cross homes sell in a quarter, and what does that mean for the median?

Few. Quarterly counts ranged from 3 sales (January to March 2026) to 15 sales (April to June 2026), and 8 sales were recorded from July to September 2026, too few to report a median for that quarter.

Where a median can be reported, it was $340,000 on 11 sales from July to September 2025, $333,000 on 10 sales from October to December 2025, and $399,000 on 15 sales from April to June 2026. With counts this small, a few homes can move a quarter's median, so we use the 12-month figures first and do not read a trend from the quarters.

How long do homes take to go under contract around Holy Cross?

Public records do not show days on market, so this answer uses ZIP Code 46201 as a whole. In October 2026 the median home in the ZIP went under contract in 52 days, against 35 days for Marion County, and that was up 84% from a year earlier as published.

In the ZIP, 38 new pending contracts were recorded in October 2026, and homes sold for 91.4% of their asking price at sale from August to October 2026, against 94.9% for the county.

Map of Marion County, Indiana ZIP Codes shaded by median days on market, October 2026. Holy Cross: 46201: 52 days. Other ZIPs: 46107: 36 days; 46113: 60 days; 46183: too few sales; 46202: 58 days; 46203: 40 days; 46204: too few sales; 46205: 35 days; 46208: 57 days; 46214: 33 days; 46216: too few sales; 46217: 25 days; 46218: 58 days; 46219: 39 days; 46220: 33 days; 46221: 16 days; 46222: 46 days; 46224: 28 days; 46225: too few sales; 46226: 52 days; 46227: 37 days; 46228: 18 days; 46229: 24 days; 46231: 15 days; 46234: 26 days; 46235: 47 days; 46236: 32 days; 46237: 46 days; 46239: 40 days; 46240: 38 days; 46241: 34 days; 46250: 29 days; 46254: 30 days; 46256: 49 days; 46259: 104 days; 46260: 14 days; 46268: 16 days; 46278: 66 days. — Median days on market by ZIP Code, October 2026. Holy Cross's ZIPs are outlined. Source: Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub.

Are listings around Holy Cross cutting their price?

In ZIP Code 46201 as a whole, 65.2% of listings had a price decrease in the three weeks to the week of Oct. 26, 2026, against 60.5% across Marion County. Homes sold for 91.4% of their original list price in that three-week average, against 94.2% for the county.

By the Housing Hub's original-list-price measure, under 96 percent is a buyer's market. That is the call for ZIP Code 46201 as a whole, and a single price range can differ, which matters here because the neighborhood's own sales sit well above the ZIP Code median.

Map of Marion County, Indiana ZIP Codes shaded by share of listings with a price decrease, Week of Oct. 26, 2026. Holy Cross: 46201: 65.2%. Other ZIPs: 46107: 51.6%; 46113: 63.0%; 46183: too few listings; 46202: 60.3%; 46203: 67.1%; 46204: 70.4%; 46205: 65.1%; 46208: 68.5%; 46214: 50.4%; 46216: too few listings; 46217: 63.6%; 46218: 58.0%; 46219: 56.0%; 46220: 61.7%; 46221: 53.2%; 46222: 60.6%; 46224: 46.5%; 46225: 67.4%; 46226: 60.7%; 46227: 62.2%; 46228: 52.8%; 46229: 62.8%; 46231: 46.7%; 46234: 69.0%; 46235: 50.9%; 46236: 51.1%; 46237: 61.7%; 46239: 62.1%; 46240: 53.3%; 46241: 47.8%; 46250: 60.5%; 46254: 59.8%; 46256: 60.2%; 46259: 64.2%; 46260: 59.1%; 46268: 47.2%; 46278: 62.0%. — Share of listings with a price decrease by ZIP Code, Week of Oct. 26, 2026. Holy Cross's ZIPs are outlined. Source: Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub.

How much is for sale around Holy Cross?

In ZIP Code 46201 as a whole, an average of 249 homes were for sale in October 2026, up 10% from a year earlier as published. Months of inventory was 6.5, against 3.7 months for Marion County.

That is a lot of competition at the ZIP Code level. A Holy Cross listing priced to the neighborhood's own recorded sales competes on condition and price band, not on the ZIP Code average.

Map of Marion County, Indiana ZIP Codes shaded by months of inventory, October 2026. Holy Cross: 46201: 6.5 mo. Other ZIPs: 46107: 2.2 mo; 46113: 3.6 mo; 46183: too few sales; 46202: 7.9 mo; 46203: 5.6 mo; 46204: 11.8 mo; 46205: 4.6 mo; 46206: too few sales; 46208: 5.0 mo; 46214: 2.8 mo; 46216: 3.8 mo; 46217: 3.1 mo; 46218: 5.2 mo; 46219: 3.7 mo; 46220: 2.3 mo; 46221: 3.0 mo; 46222: 3.7 mo; 46224: 2.4 mo; 46225: 6.6 mo; 46226: 3.1 mo; 46227: 3.4 mo; 46228: 3.1 mo; 46229: 4.0 mo; 46231: 2.8 mo; 46234: 3.0 mo; 46235: 4.0 mo; 46236: 1.9 mo; 46237: 3.4 mo; 46239: 3.6 mo; 46240: 2.5 mo; 46241: 3.1 mo; 46250: 3.3 mo; 46254: 2.6 mo; 46256: 2.3 mo; 46259: 4.8 mo; 46260: 2.8 mo; 46268: 3.2 mo; 46278: 3.3 mo. — Months of inventory by ZIP Code, October 2026. Holy Cross's ZIPs are outlined. Source: Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub.

Where we stand on Holy Cross price forecasts

Our view at Mark Dietel Realty: We report what happened and what it means for your price range. We do not predict prices. Anyone who tells you exactly where prices will be next spring is guessing.

Your options for selling a Holy Cross home

There is more than one way to sell a Holy Cross home. We will lay them side by side with your numbers so you can choose.

List on the market

Usually the highest price, if you have time to prepare and show the home.

A local agent walks through your home
Recent sales at your price, side by side
A pricing and preparation plan for your first weeks on the market

Guaranteed sale

For sellers who need to know the home will sell before they make their next move. Conditions apply.

We agree on the price up front
Plan your move around a known outcome

Cash offer

Speed and certainty. Sell as-is, on your timeline.

No repairs or showings
See how a cash price compares with listing

A cash offer trades price for speed and certainty. If your home is in good shape and you have time, a cash offer usually means taking less. It can make sense when repairs, timing or certainty matter more than price.

Who this may not be right for

You may not need a listing agent if you already have a buyer, you are comfortable pricing from public sold data, and you are ready to handle disclosures, showings, negotiation and closing paperwork yourself, or with a real estate attorney. Many people sell that way. If that is you, we will tell you so.

We are a team: you work with a listing agent backed by inside sales, coordinators and a transaction coordinator. Some sellers want one person for every call, start to finish. If that matters more to you than a team system, a solo agent may fit you better.

Questions Holy Cross sellers ask us

How long does it take to sell a house in Holy Cross?

In October 2026 the median home in ZIP Code 46201 as a whole went under contract in 52 days (Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub). Closing usually follows the contract by several weeks, depending on the buyer's financing.

Should I wait to sell my Holy Cross home?

We report what happened and what it means for your price range. We do not predict prices. Anyone who tells you exactly where prices will be next spring is guessing. The better question is what your plan looks like at today's numbers.

Where do these Holy Cross figures come from?

The sale prices are recorded home sales from public records for the Holy Cross Neighborhood Association area, which include homes sold without a listing. Days on market and price cuts are not in those records, so we use ZIP Code 46201 figures for them and label them that way.

Why is the Holy Cross median so far above the ZIP Code median?

The neighborhood's median of $362,750 comes from 36 recorded sales from October 2025 to September 2026, while ZIP Code 46201 as a whole had a median sale price of $167,750 from August to October 2026. They are different groups of homes, so price a Holy Cross home from the neighborhood's own sales.

More for Holy Cross sellers

Sources: Indiana Department of Local Government Finance sales disclosure data via STATS Indiana (stats.indiana.edu), home sales recorded in Marion County through September 2026; neighborhood boundary from the City of Indianapolis (IndyGIS); addresses located with the U.S. Census Bureau geocoder. ZIP Code 46201 figures as published by the Indiana REALTORS Housing Hub (data.indianarealtors.com): median sale price, three-month average, August to October 2026; median days on market, months of inventory and inventory October 2026; price decreases and sale price as a share of original list price, three-week average to the week of Oct. 26, 2026. ZIP areas: U.S. Census Bureau. Maps: OpenStreetMap contributors. Recorded sales include homes sold without a listing.

This page is general information about the Holy Cross market, not an appraisal or a valuation of any specific home.

Holy Cross Real Estate Market: Home Prices and Trends